Summary
- Considering a third quarter that was shaping up to be a challenging one for financial institutions, Citigroup did not disappoint.
- Consumer banking looked solid as expected, while the institutional client segment offered a mixed bag of good and uninspiring results.
- In my view, Citigroup is a mile behind its best-of-breed peer JPMorgan, but bargain-hunters might see value in owning this stock.
- Looking for a helping hand in the market? Members of Storm-Resistant Growth get exclusive ideas and guidance to navigate any climate. Get started today »
It could have been much worse.
The third quarter was shaping up to be a challenging one for financial institutions, considering a scenario of spread compression, unresolved trade wars, deteriorated business sentiment, Brexit drama and volatility in the markets. Within this context, Citigroup's (NYSE:C) 3Q19 results should not be considered weak. But, at the same time, upon taking a closer look at the earnings report, I did not find enough reasons to turn any more bullish on the bank and its stock.
Credit: GreenBiz
Down the middle
Strong performance in consumer banking (about 47% of Citi's total revenues) was not a surprise. Nothing seems capable of slowing down consumer activity, supported in great part by leverage as overall non-housing debt in the U.S. continues to rise at a near 4% per-year pace since just prior to the start of the 2008 recession (or almost 6% per year over the past five years). Citi's average retail banking deposits in the quarter increased by 3% worldwide, while credit card loan balances grew 4%. Interest margin within the consumer segment seemed relatively stable, as the dark blue bars in the chart below suggest - YOY growth of 5% in net interest revenue.
Performance in institutional clients (the other 50%-plus of Citi's total revenues in the quarter) was far from disappointing, as both banking and market revenues were up modestly YOY despite the macro headwinds mentioned in the first paragraph above. But Citigroup may have suffered from tough peer comparison against JPMorgan (JPM) which, on the same day, reported strong double-digit revenue growth in the institutional space and reportedly took market share away from its competitors. Citigroup's remarks that its banking and market revenues in 4Q19 "should reflect the overall environment", which is not a particularly favorable one, may have set investors' expectations low for the near-term future.

