New York Community Bancorp: A Buyable Dip

Summary

  • NYCB stock declined 14% on the release of Q3 earnings due to worries over a lack of balance sheet growth.
  • This lack of growth in the balance sheet is unlikely to be the beginning of a new normal.
  • Meanwhile, NIM and NII have reached an inflection point and should improve in every quarter throughout 2020.

Readers of my articles over the years are likely well aware that New York Community Bancorp (NYCB) became my largest position in 2018. While I was a little early getting into the position (I usually am), it has still turned out to be a very well-timed investment, considering the fact that NYCB's Net Interest Income, or NII, and Net Interest Margin, or NIM, are reaching their inflection point and turning higher as we speak. This shift towards higher margins will absolutely drive earnings per share higher in 2020 and 2021.

Investors had gotten ahead of this inflection point by buying NYCB shares aggressively in 2019. The stock has rallied 27% since the beginning of the year, all while paying a very generous dividend.

But with the large share price decline following Q3 earnings, some investors may be wondering if NYCB's rally has staying power, and if this dip is a buying opportunity. I believe the answer to those questions is a resounding yes. New York Community Bancorp will likely see growth in both its net interest margin and net interest income in every quarter in 2020, with estimates for NIM approaching 2.25% by year-end 2020, up from today's 1.99%.

This type of margin improvement will push earnings per share up by double-digits, dramatically lower NYCB's payout ratio, push NYCB's book value even higher than it already is, and support balance sheet growth, whether organic or acquired. Meanwhile, you can still collect a 5.62% dividend while you hold this stock, which is a rare find considering what appears to be a very easy path to double-digit EPS growth over the next couple of years.

ChartData by YCharts

The post-earnings 14% price decline

New York Community Bancorp's shares declined by 14% intraday at their worst point after Q3 earnings were released. The most often stated reason for the price action was the stalling of balance sheet growth. The worries over balance growth bring up all too recent memories of the battle over rent-regulated apartment buildings in New York City, with bears claiming that the recent changes to rent regulations will no doubt lead to a decline in purchase volume, as well as investors refinancing out of NYCB's products and into Fannie (OTC:FDDXD) and Freddie's (OTCQB:FMCC) longer-term commercial products.

The jury is still out on exactly how much rent regulation changes will impact NYCB, but with its stock price trading at a 52-week high going into earnings, many traders ran for the exit as soon as the market opened following the release of Q3 numbers, which indeed showed no growth in NYCB’s balance sheet from Q2 to Q3.

I don't want to mislead readers by implying that stalled balance sheet growth isn't a problem. But it needs to be understood that one quarter does not make a trend. Average loan balances were up 5% year over year for the quarter, which implies that the loss of loans all took place at the very end of Q3.

Indeed, management indicated on the conference call that it was a result of several large loans being refinanced away in the last weeks of the quarter. The good news is that year to date, NYCB still shows 2% growth in its balance sheet, and NYCB's $2.2 billion pipeline of new loans up 10% over last quarter, which implies that Q3’s lack of growth was indeed a fluke, rather than a trend.

In the multi-family portfolio specifically, NYCB has $1.3 billion in the pipeline for Q4. Assuming these loans all close, that would bring full-year 2019 originations to $5.3 billion, a decline from 2018 but still enough to more than offset the runoff of older loans.

In addition, NYCB is still rapidly growing its specialty finance portfolio, which showed 23% growth last quarter, and the option is always there to add to the securities portfolio which, even with falling interest rates, can provide a positive margin.

READ FULL ARTICLE HERE